Tennis and Stuff Banner

Ranking System.

Is the ranking system in Women's tennis flawed??
I know, I know.. this topic has been beat to death, but I still don't know what's going on with the WTA ranking system. This year isn't the only year this has happened, I think you know what I'm talking about, how a player like Dinara Safina (Do not get me wrong, she's an amazing, amazing player) getting to the top of the tennis world without having a grand slam title on your resume?

The ranking system the WTA uses currently is modeled after the same ranking system used on the ATP Tour which awards points based on results in tournaments, and caps it off after a certain number of tournaments. For the 2009 season the WTA is capping that at 16 events. 

So, if a player completes in more than 16 events, only the best 16 results will count towards their ranking, so if they perform poorly in some events those can be dropped without any worries. I believe this is where the main flaw lies in the WTA ranking system.

But back to the WTA's current number 1 player, Dinara Safina. She's held the ranking for 12 months now, and she's had an amazing 12 months along the way..last year she was ranked number 17 in the world, but in that time she's reached the finals at the Australian Open and Roland Garros, the olympics, and she's also won 4 WTA tournaments.

But she still doesn't have a major title on her resume.

Safina replaced Serena Williams as the world number 1, even though Williams won the US Open and Australian Open, and reached the finals of Wimbledon last year, and won it this year. Yet she's still #2.

Your thoughts, opinions..feel free to add on any other flaws you see in the ranking system..


What's on your mind? Post a comment below.
 
Posted by Neemesh Chheda on 9/30/2009 4:40:39 PM
Filed under: Rankning, System, WTA



Current rating: 0 (0 ratings)

Bookmark this page to:Add to Facebook Add to Delicious Add to Twitter Add to Reddit Add to StumbleUpon Add to Digg Add to MySpace Add to Google Bookmarks

Share Your Thoughts: To leave a comment Sign in or Register for a Tennis Now account.
Comments
Geoff K
I don't think the system is flawed at all -- I think if you change the balance between the points given for Slams and those for regular tour tourneys any more than it is now, you risk downgrading the prestige and importance of the latter (which do a lot for fostering interest in tennis around the world) and reward players (I won't name any names) for giving less than their best (or not even playing) in the regular tour events. One reason there's not any controversy about the men's ranking system is that the top players consistently play and win the tour events in addition to the slams, so there's no chance of a consistent performer like Davydenko or Djokovic taking over the number one spot.
10/2/2009 2:06:31 PM
 
Geoff K
All the hoopla about Safina not deserving her top rank could be a moot point soon -- she lost another early round match and will drop in the rankings sooner rather than later!
10/5/2009 4:16:27 PM
 
Neemesh Chheda
I saw that! Losing to someone that low..she's done!
10/6/2009 4:14:08 PM
 
Leave comment
Name:

E-mail:

Comments:

 
Enter security code:
 Security code





Featured Tennis Blogs

Tennis and Stuff
Nick Bolletieri's Tennis Blog
Serving Up Top Tennis Players
Tennis Gets Me Giddy
Legends Of The Game
The War Room Blog

Post Archive

February 2012(6)
January 2012(7)
December 2011(33)
November 2011(7)
October 2011(5)
September 2011(14)
August 2011(13)
July 2011(8)
June 2011(23)
May 2011(14)
April 2011(23)
March 2011(3)
February 2011(1)
January 2011(17)
December 2010(3)
November 2010(17)
October 2010(6)
September 2010(30)
August 2010(30)
July 2010(22)
June 2010(11)
May 2010(7)
April 2010(4)
March 2010(7)
February 2010(1)
January 2010(7)
December 2009(10)
November 2009(16)
October 2009(11)
September 2009(5)

Latest Blog Comments

2/1/2012
luckytennis
If US tennis players follow me, US will win Davis Cup and F...

2/1/2012
Patrick
Hey there, I agree with Lee. Caroline is really not hot, so...

2/1/2012
OOT
><span id="plcRoot_Layout_zoneContent_SubContent_SubCont...

1/27/2012
storty
very great post tanks for sharig<br /> <a href="http://www...

1/27/2012
storty
very great post tanks for sharig<br /> <a href="http://www...

1/25/2012
Jackson
Do you make fun of blind people too?

1/24/2012
luckytennis
Djokovic will beat Murray, Nadal will beat Roger go to Fina...

1/23/2012
Cameron
Really Rafael Nadal is world greast player and this is agre...

1/21/2012
Deana Williams
I like Ted Lepak. Good Add, Tennis Now!<br />

1/21/2012
Terri Hills
Hope your predictions are right! I have been supporting And...

|< < 1   2   3 > >| 1 - 10 of 1405 From Page 1 of 141

Community Shortcuts